Creation and Criticism

Traditional teaching methods in professional communication often place undue emphasis on the teacher, leading to passive learning environments where students are mainly recipients of information rather than active participants in the learning process. This approach tends to prioritize rote memorization over the development of critical communicative skills. In the context of Precis Writing, such methods may hinder students’ ability to effectively summarize and convey ideas succinctly. To address these challenges, the case study method offers a strategic alternative that promotes a more interactive, student-centered approach. By integrating case studies into the teaching of Precis Writing, educators can create dynamic learning environments where students engage in real-world scenarios, apply their language skills, and develop a deeper understanding of content. Through case studies, students actively practice the art of condensing information, refining their writing, and engaging in collaborative discussions that enhance both their linguistic and cognitive abilities. This method fosters critical thinking, improves writing clarity, and encourages the internalization of key grammatical structures and vocabulary. Ultimately, the case study approach in Precis Writing not only supports the development of professional communication skills but also cultivates essential life skills such as problem-solving, teamwork, and emotional intelligence. The findings of this study offer valuable insights for educational institutions, both in India and globally, aiming to modernize language pedagogy and improve communication proficiency through innovative, task-based learning strategies.

Keywords: Professional Communication, Case Study Method, Precis Writing, Task-Based Learning (TBL), Interactive Learning, Student-Centered Approach, Language Pedagogy, Writing Skills, Collaborative Learning, Language Acquisition.

1. Introduction

“Cases are stories with a message. They are not simply narratives for entertainment. They are stories to educate” (Herreid 41). This definition highlights the dual nature of a case study: it serves not only as a narrative but also as a powerful pedagogical tool. So, what elements of a story make it an effective teaching tool for professional communication? The answer lies in the story’s capacity to engage, persuade, and motivate learners. Stories naturally capture attention through relatable experiences and emotional resonance, making them ideal vehicles for meaningful learning. Case studies can take many forms— ranging from songs, poems, and articles to news reports, images, online videos, dialogues, precis, feedback, and real-life scenarios. These materials bridge the gap between classroom learning and real-world communication, fostering a deeper understanding of language use in various contexts.

As Jeremy Hsu (2008) notes, “Perhaps because theory of mind is so vital to social living, once we possess it we tend to imagine minds everywhere, making stories out of everything.” This human tendency to interpret and make sense of the world through stories makes the case-based approach particularly effective for teaching professional communication. By using case studies, educators can tap into students’ innate desire for narrative, facilitating a more dynamic learning experience.

In the context of the Indian education system, numerous challenges undermine the effective instruction of professional communication. Traditional lecture-centric teaching methods, often outdated and rigid, prevail. Furthermore, there is a shortage of well-trained educators, and many teachers face significant pressure to rush through syllabi to meet examination demands. This, coupled with increasing clerical duties and distractions from digital media, contributes to disengagement and a lack of meaningful interaction. Additionally, low student attendance and limited proficiency in English create barriers to effective language instruction, resulting in monotonous classrooms and diminishing creativity.

In light of these challenges, the case study approach presents a practical and impactful alternative. By shifting the focus to learner-centered, real-world scenarios, case studies foster greater student engagement and stimulate interest in all four core language skills— listening, speaking, reading, and writing. They also promote critical thinking, as students analyze, interpret, and respond to authentic communication challenges. Through case studies, learners can better contextualize their language skills in real-life situations, which not only enhances their linguistic proficiency but also develops their cognitive abilities to navigate an interconnected and digital world.

In particular, integrating case studies with précis writing further enriches the learning process. Précis writing, which involves “summarizing” (Wren & Martin 362) information concisely and accurately, helps students refine their ability to express ideas clearly and succinctly. It “facilitates the students to summarize reading texts by noting important points from the text and then use them in their writing” (Jannah 43). When combined with case studies, précis writing provides a focused approach to analyzing and synthesizing complex narratives, encouraging learners to think critically about communication while improving their writing skills. This blend of case study-based learning and précis writing equips students with the communicative competencies necessary to succeed in both academic and real-world environments.

1.1. Case Study Approach in Professional Communication

Strategic integration involves the intentional planning and thoughtful application of teaching methods to meet clearly defined educational goals. When it comes to teaching professional communication, strategically employing the case study method means more than simply selecting stories or scenarios— it involves embedding these cases into the learning process to enhance practical communication skills. A case study serves as both a narrative for learning and a teaching strategy that encourages active engagement through problem-based, real-world scenarios. As Popil (2011) notes, the approach is often referred to as “the case method” (p. 205), and its academic origins can be traced back to the 1870s when Harvard University first introduced it in “business and law schools” (Kaddouro 7). Since then, its use has expanded across disciplines, including the humanities and social sciences.

In Professional Communication Classrooms (PCCs), the case study method offers a learner-centered approach, shifting the focus from passive reception to active participation. This method creates an environment where students can analyze, discuss, and solve problems drawn from realistic or simulated contexts, helping them internalize language as a tool for authentic communication. Rather than relying solely on memorization, students apply language in dynamic, context-rich situations that mirror real-life interactions.

As Nitin Nohria (2021) emphasizes, “Cases teach students how to apply theory in practice and how to induce theory from practice.” This dual purpose highlights the effectiveness of the method: it reinforces theoretical knowledge while cultivating critical life skills such as analysis, judgment, and effective decision-making. When strategically implemented, the case study approach enhances communicative competence by fostering interactive dialogue, critical reflection, and collaborative problem-solving.

By integrating case studies into the curriculum of professional communication, educators create an engaging classroom atmosphere where learners actively contribute and apply their language skills. The case study approach empowers students to function confidently in diverse communicative environments, whether in academic, professional, or social contexts. However, the success of this method hinges on thoughtful planning: the careful selection of relevant cases, ensuring alignment with the communicative learning objectives, and balancing language fluency with practical skill development.

1.2. Purpose of Learning Professional Communication

Professional communication involves the active exchange of ideas and information using English language as a medium. Its purpose extends far beyond scoring well in exams, securing employment, or meeting career goals. At its core, learning professional communication equips individuals with the essential productive and receptive language skills— Listening, Speaking, Reading, and Writing (LSRW)— that enable meaningful interaction in both social and professional contexts.

Effective communication in English empowers learners to confidently express their thoughts, engage with diverse perspectives, and navigate real-world situations with clarity and precision. As Raman and Singh (2006) emphasize, “Achieving success in the workplace is closely associated with the ability to communicate effectively, both in the workplace and with outsiders” (p. 3). Thus, communicative competence is not merely a linguistic goal but a life skill.

In this context, the teacher’s role becomes crucial, not just as an instructor, but as a facilitator who guides learners in applying language meaningfully. The case study method offers a practical pathway for this, allowing students to use language in realistic, problem-solving scenarios. This strategic approach helps learners build confidence, improve fluency, and develop the courage to articulate their ideas across various fields of knowledge and experience.

2. Implementing the Case Study Approach in Teaching Professional Communication

2.1. Understanding the Foundations

Research indicates that engaging students in case studies, whether individually or in groups, significantly enhances their cognitive skills and their ability to process information in communicative contexts. This approach encourages students to move beyond simple recall and engage in higher-level thinking, which is essential for effective communication. More importantly, case studies foster critical thinking, as students must interpret and analyze information, leading to a deeper understanding of the subject matter.

The teacher’s role is pivotal in the success of this approach. Before each session, instructors must clearly define the learning objectives, choose appropriate case study topics, and design materials that align with students’ communicative goals. For example, if the goal is to improve media writing, the teacher may provide a case study involving two contrasting media-related precis exercises— one exemplary and one flawed— along with a set of guidelines for evaluation and improvement.

2.2. Steps to Implementing Case Study Approach in Teaching Professional Communication

2.2.1. Preparing the Case Study Content

Teachers have the option of either creating original case studies or curating relevant material from trusted resources. Regardless of the source, the content of precis writing should be engaging, pedagogically appropriate, and designed to challenge students to think critically. Teachers must ensure that the case studies are contextually relevant and will effectively contribute to learners’ communicative skills in English.

2.2.2. Selecting Appropriate Case Study Topics

Case studies should focus on real-world communicative challenges that are relevant to precis writing and broader communicative skills in English. These case studies should stimulate thought, encourage discussion, and promote the application of language skills through the process of summarization and paraphrasing. Topics for case studies should be designed to match students’ needs and interests, and may include themes such as: 'Summarizing Complex News Articles for Clarity', 'Paraphrasing Opinions in Public Debates', 'Effective Written Communication in Business Correspondence', 'Summarizing Academic Texts for Presentations', and 'Synthesizing Information from Multiple Sources'. Such topics allow students to explore both language mechanics and higher-level communication strategies, encouraging them to think critically about how language can be condensed, clarified, and communicated effectively. This approach not only sharpens their précis writing skills but also enhances their overall communicative competence, preparing them for a variety of real-world writing and speaking scenarios.

2.2.3. Structuring the Learning Environment

For case study-based teaching to be effective, the classroom environment must promote active participation. Teachers should organize the classroom layout to encourage interaction, such as arranging desks in a U-shape or small groups. This setup fosters better communication, making it easier for students to engage in discussions, share ideas, and collaborate on solving case-related problems.

2.2.4. Presenting the Case to Students

Once the case study material is prepared, the teacher's next task is to introduce it to the students. This begins with grouping students and presenting the background of the case. Teachers should clearly explain any difficult vocabulary, grammatical structures, and conceptual aspects, ensuring that all students understand the context and objectives of the case. Through structured discussion, problem-solving, and exploration of resources, the teacher guides students in analyzing the case. As Bonney (2015) notes, “This approach enhances student engagement, which in turn boosts “motivation and learning outcomes” (p. 21).

2.2.5. Encouraging Active Student Participation

The success of case study teaching depends heavily on student participation. Teachers should begin each session by outlining learning objectives and guiding students on how to engage with the case study. Encouraging students to take notes, ask questions, and share their insights helps promote a more dynamic learning experience. Active involvement ensures that students develop both linguistic and cognitive skills necessary for effective communication in English.

2.2.6. Assessment and Feedback Mechanisms

Effective assessment is integral to the case study approach. Teachers should use clear rubrics to evaluate student performance in speaking, writing, listening, and problem-solving. Feedback should be timely, constructive, and focused on helping students improve. Teachers can provide individual or group-based assessments, offering both positive reinforcement and areas for further improvement. Transparent grading criteria and constructive feedback help students understand their progress and motivate them to refine their skills.

2.2.7. The Teacher’s Role as a Facilitator

In the case study approach, teachers act as facilitators rather than traditional lecturers. They guide students through the process of analysis, offer support when necessary, and encourage active learning. Teachers should observe students’ interactions, provide feedback, and suggest strategies to improve performance. This facilitative approach helps students develop independence in their learning, while also allowing them to refine their communication skills in a supportive environment.

2.2.8. Recognizing Student Contributions

To foster a sense of ownership and motivation, it is essential for teachers to acknowledge and value the contributions of students. During discussions, teachers should highlight key points raised by students, affirming their input and encouraging further participation. Recognizing contributions not only boosts their confidence but also reinforces the collaborative nature of case-based learning, making them feel integral to the learning process.

3. Benefits of the Case Study Approach in Teaching Professional Communication

The case study approach offers numerous benefits for both students and teachers in the professional communication classroom. By actively engaging with case studies, students can gather, analyze, and apply information to solve real-world communication problems. This process not only deepens their understanding of English but also promotes valuable soft skills. For teachers, case studies provide a window into student performance, allowing for targeted support and feedback.

The advantages of incorporating case studies into professional communication instruction are multi-faceted. These include:

3.1. Enhanced Group Communication and Collaboration

Through case study activities, students have the opportunity to work collaboratively in small groups. This fosters an environment of peer-to-peer learning, where students exchange ideas, articulate opinions, and solve problems collectively. As a result, their ability to communicate effectively in group settings improves, a crucial skill in both professional and personal contexts.

3.2. Development of Critical Thinking and Problem-Solving Skills

Case studies push students to think critically and analyze complex situations. By working through real-world problems, they learn to apply language skills in a practical manner, enhancing their decision-making abilities. This process also strengthens their problem-solving skills, both qualitatively and quantitatively, depending on the nature of the case.

3.3. Improvement in Analytical Abilities

Students are encouraged to analyze case scenarios from multiple angles, evaluate various outcomes, and synthesize information to arrive at well-reasoned conclusions. This helps them develop a strong foundation in analytical thinking, which is essential not only in language learning but also in navigating complex communicative contexts.

3.4. Increased Confidence and Decision-Making Power

Case studies often place students in situations where they must make decisions based on the information available. This decision-making process, particularly in ambiguous or uncertain scenarios, helps build their confidence in their ability to navigate challenging communicative situations. Over time, this can enhance their overall communicative competence.

3.5. Clarification of Ambiguities and Misunderstandings

In professional communication, misinterpretations and ambiguities are common, especially for non-native speakers. By engaging with case studies, students can explore real-life examples of misunderstandings and learn how to clarify or resolve them. This process sharpens their ability to communicate more clearly and effectively, reducing the risk of miscommunication in real-life situations.

3.6. Application of Knowledge to Career Development

Beyond language acquisition, case studies in professional communication help students apply their knowledge to practical, career-oriented contexts. By working on cases that simulate real workplace or social communication scenarios, students gain transferable skills that are highly valued by employers. This makes them better prepared for job opportunities and career advancement in environments where effective communication is key.

4. Challenges in Implementing the Case Study Approach

While the case study approach offers numerous benefits, both teachers and students face certain challenges in its effective implementation, particularly when it is integrated with précis writing to teach professional communication. For teachers, selecting the right case study that aligns with students’ linguistic abilities and learning needs can be a time-consuming task. It requires careful planning to ensure the case is both appropriate and engaging, facilitating the development of students’ ability to summarize, paraphrase, and express ideas clearly. Additionally, without strategic planning and active student engagement, the method risks not achieving its full potential in helping students improve their writing and communication skills.

For students, particularly non-native speakers, understanding the nuances of the English language, such as idiomatic expressions, complex sentence structures, or cultural references, can pose significant challenges in the précis writing process. This can hinder their ability to condense and rephrase information accurately. Despite these challenges, the overall advantages of using the case study approach in précis writing far outweigh the difficulties. It offers students valuable opportunities to enhance their linguistic skills, think critically about language use, and improve their ability to communicate concisely and effectively. Therefore, despite the hurdles, this approach remains a highly effective pedagogical tool for teaching professional communication.

5. Case Study Approach: Precis Writing in Professional Communication

Situation: How to Approach a Precis Writing?

In this model case study, the focus is on Precis Writing, a crucial skill in developing both writing and reading comprehension abilities in professional communication. Precis writing involves condensing a long piece of text into a shorter, more concise version while retaining the essential meaning. “In other words, it should supply the summary of the original views in one’s own words without leaving out any of the essentials” (Chauhan 6). The teacher begins by explaining the purpose of precis writing and its importance in effectively communicating complex ideas in a clear and brief manner.

The teacher first introduces the text to be summarized, highlighting key features such as the main ideas, themes, and supporting arguments. Students are encouraged to read the text carefully and identify the “key ideas and concepts” (Koneru 337), avoiding unnecessary details and focusing on the central ideas. The teacher demonstrates how to approach this process step-by-step, starting with identifying the key statement, then extracting the key points, and finally, rephrasing the content using concise language.

The teacher also provides strategies for paraphrasing— transforming long, complex sentences into clear and simple ones without changing the meaning. Additionally, students are instructed to avoid personal opinions, ensuring that the precis remains an objective summary of the original text. The emphasis is placed on using correct grammar, appropriate vocabulary, and maintaining a logical flow in the written summary.

To reinforce the learning process, students are then asked to write their own precis of the same text. Once the students complete their drafts, the teacher facilitates a peer review session, where students exchange their precis and provide constructive feedback to each other. This encourages collaboration and helps students refine their writing skills through critical evaluation.

Finally, the teacher concludes the session by reviewing common mistakes students make, such as including too many details, deviating from the main point, or failing to keep the precis concise. The teacher provides individual feedback to students, suggesting improvements and offering further practice opportunities for those who need extra support.

5.1. Student Assessment Framework

To assess students’ progress in Precis Writing, a comprehensive Student Assessment Form is used, covering key areas like writing clarity, grammar, conciseness, and accuracy. The form rates students’ performance on a scale: 1 (Very Poor), 2 (Below Average), 3 (Average), 4 (Above Average), and 5 (Excellent) for each criterion. Specific remarks are provided to help guide students’ development.

Here’s how the assessment is structured:

Skill Area	1	2	3	4	5
Writing Clarity
Grammar
Conciseness
Accuracy of Content
Consistency

Remarks: Teachers provide targeted feedback, such as “The précis is well-structured, but more effort is needed to remove extraneous details,” or “The grammar is strong, but the summary could be more concise.” This feedback ensures that students understand their strengths and areas for improvement.

5.2. Application in the Classroom

During the precis writing activity, students engage with the text, applying their comprehension skills to extract the key information. The teacher observes how each student handles the task, offering real-time feedback and providing additional guidance where necessary. Group discussions allow students to compare their approaches to writing a précis, fostering collaborative learning and improving their ability to condense information in a structured way.

This exercise helps students practice important aspects of writing, such as clarity, brevity, and accuracy, all essential for effective communication. It also allows them to refine their ability to summarize large amounts of information, a valuable skill in both academic and professional settings.

By providing individualized feedback through the Student Assessment Form, the teacher ensures that each student receives the necessary guidance to improve their précis writing skills, enabling them to become more proficient in expressing ideas succinctly and clearly in professional communication.

6. Conclusion

The case study approach plays a crucial role in enhancing professional communication through Precis Writing by providing a dynamic, learner-centered framework that engages students in real-world, task-based learning. By focusing on the practice of summarizing and condensing texts, case studies help students understand the nuances of Precis Writing while strengthening their language proficiency and communication skills. This method encourages active participation, allowing students to engage with complex material, develop their writing clarity, and connect theoretical knowledge to practical applications. Furthermore, it fosters collaborative learning environments where students work together to solve problems, reflect on their language use, and improve their written communication. By integrating case studies into the teaching of Precis Writing, educators create a more interactive and engaging learning experience that is both relevant and impactful. Ultimately, this approach empowers students to become more confident and competent communicators, capable of effectively conveying ideas in various contexts, while also honing critical thinking, writing, and summarization skills essential for their academic and professional success.

Works Cited:

Bonney, Kevin M. “Case Study Teaching Method Improves Student Performance and Perceptions of Learning Gains.” Journal of Microbiology & Biology Education, vol. 16, no. 1, 2015, pp. 21-28. https://doi.org/10.1128/jmbe.v16i1.846

Chauhan, A.S. Writing Skills. Lap Lambert Academic Publishing, 2012.

Herreid, Clyde Freeman. “What is a Case? Bringing to Science Education the Established Teaching Tool of Law and Medicine.” Start with a Story: The Case Study Method of Teaching College Science, edited by Clyde Freeman Herreid. NSTA Press, 2007, pp. 41-44

Hsu, Jeremy. “The Secrets of Storytelling: Why We Love a Good Yarn: Our love for telling tales reveals the workings of the mind.” Scientific American, August 1, 2008. www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-secrets-of-storytelling/

Jannah, Miftahul. “Effects of Precis-Writing on Students’ Recount Writing at English Laboratory of Universitas Bandar Lampung. Etnolingual, vol. 3, no. 1, 2019, pp. 43–56. https://doi.org/10.20473/etno.v3i1.12699

Kaddouro, Mahmoud A. “Critical Thinking Skills of Nursing Students in Lecture-based Teaching and Case-based Learning.” International Journal for the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning, vol. 5, no. 2, 2011, pp. 1–18. https://doi.org/10.20429/ijsotl.2011.050220

Koneru, Aruna. Professional Communication. McGraw Hill Education (India), 2016.

Nitin Nohria. “What the Case Study Method Really Teaches.” Harvard Business Review, Dec 21, 2021. www.hbr.org/2021/12/what-the-case-study-method-really-teaches

Popil, Inna. “Promotion of critical thinking by using case studies as teaching method.” Nurse Education Today, vol. 31, no. 2, 2011, pp. 204–207. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2010.06.002

Raman, Meenakshi and Prakash Singh. Business Communication. Oxford University Press, 2016.

Wren, P.C. and H. Martin. High School English Grammar & Composition. Blackie ELT Books, 2018.

About the Author:

Abnish Singh Chauhan/ अवनीश सिंह चौहान (b. 1979) is a bilingual poet, short story writer, critic, translator and editor of Poorvabhas and Creation and Criticism. He has authored/edited 15 books, including two collections of poetry and a book on poetry translation, and contributed over 100 articles, book reviews, and research papers to prominent journals, magazines, and newspapers in Hindi and English. Currently, he is a Professor and Founding Head, Department of English, as well as Founding Principal of BIU College of Humanities and Journalism at Bareilly International University, Bareilly, Uttar Pradesh, India. He can be reached at abnishsinghchauhan@gmail.com.